Enter your ZIP to find local pros.
Please enter a valid 5 digit zip code

Which Roof Shingle is Best For You?

Use our tool to find your best matches or scroll to read about all roof types.

Tell us about your climate

What do you most want your new roof shingle to do?

Does your area have any of the following concerns?

(Click all that apply)

Here are your top matches

Click on the shingle types to see them on the house

$1.71-$7.00per square foot
$23.81-$43.42per square foot
$6-$9.50per square foot
$6.65-$12.13per square foot
$4.25-$8.25per square foot
$4-$8per square foot
$8.26-$15.25per square foot
You may also like

Asphalt Shingles

  • Come in cheap 3-tab or more attractive architectural varieties.
  • Withstand wildfires and high-winds.
  • Most popular shingle type.
  • Lifespan of 20-30 years.
Learn more

Metal Shingles

  • Great appearance. Come in several colors.
  • Lifespan of 40-80 years.
  • Extremely weather- and fire-resistant.
  • Reduce energy costs.
Learn more

Wood Shake/Shingles

  • Beautiful appearance.
  • Comes in shingles or shakes.
  • Not suitable for areas with extreme temps or weather patterns.
Learn more

Slate Tile

  • Beautiful appearance.
  • Lifespan of 60-150 years.
  • Extremely weather-resistant.
  • Very heavy; roof may need to be reinforced before installation.
Learn more

Rubber Roof Shingles

  • Can be made to resemble other materials.
  • Excellent for keeping heat out and suitable for cold climates.
  • Lifespan of 15-30 years.
Learn more

Composite Plastic Shingles

  • Lightweight and affordable
  • Suitable for cold climates.
  • Lifespan of 7-20 years.
Learn more

Clay Tile Shingles

  • Excellent at absorbing heat during the day and releasing it at night, keeping utility bills low.
  • Withstands heat and wildfires well.
  • Beautiful appearance.
  • Long lifespan.
Learn more

Find the best roofing pros in your area.

The Modernize Mission

We help homeowners make confident decisions through our reliable, up-to-date, and unbiased information and average project costs. All of our content is thoroughly reviewed and fact-checked by our team of home improvement experts. Learn more about how we maintain these values.

Types of Roof Shingles

When most people think of types of roof shingles, asphalt comes to mind — and for good reason. Asphalt shingles are by far the most common and affordable choice. But they’re far from your only option.

From timeless cedar wood to sleek metal and even energy-producing solar shingles, there’s a wide variety of roofing shingle types to consider. Each type comes with unique advantages, drawbacks, and maintenance needs.

This guide will walk you through the most popular types of roof shingles, focusing on what sets them apart in durability, appearance, and performance, so you can make the right decision for your home.

» Note: If you’re researching costs, check out our Roof Shingle Cost Guide

Shingle Type Features
Shingle TypeRelative Cost*LifespanKey Features
Asphalt ShinglesLow15 to 50 yrsAffordable, versatile
Wood (Cedar)Medium to High20 to 25 yrsNatural, rustic, higher maintenance
CompositeLow to Medium7 to 20 yrsLightweight, mimics slate/wood
MetalMedium to High50 to 100+ yrsDurable, energy-efficient
SlateHigh60 to 150 yrsPremium, natural stone
SolarHigh20 to 30 yrsGenerates clean energy
RubberMedium15 to 30 yrsEco-friendly, impact-resistant
Tile (Clay/Concrete)HighUp to 100 yrsClassic, long-lasting

*For detailed pricing breakdowns, see our Roof Shingle Cost Guide or our Roof Replacement Cost Calculator

Asphalt Roof Shingles

Asphalt shingles are America’s favorite for a reason: they’re affordable, easy to install, and available in tons of colors. Whether you’re replacing a roof or starting from scratch, asphalt offers a solid, budget-friendly solution. They come in several varieties:

  • 3-Tab Shingles: Flat, uniform, and most affordable. Best for budget-conscious homeowners.
  • Architectural Shingles: Layered look, better durability, one of the most common installations today.
  • Luxury Shingles: Designed to mimic slate or wood shakes, offering premium aesthetics at a lower cost.

Lifespan: 15 to 50 years
Appearance: Traditional and versatile
Performance: Reliable fire/weather resistance, quick installation

» Looking for pricing? Explore our detailed Asphalt Shingle Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Affordable upfront
    • Quick to install
    • Wide availability
  • Cons

    • Can wear out faster in harsh climates
    • Shorter lifespan than premium materials

Wood (Cedar) Shakes & Shingles

Cedar shingles add warmth and timeless character to a home. They offer a natural, textured appearance that many homeowners love. Shingles are cut for a smooth, uniform look, while shakes are thicker and split for a rugged, rustic style.

Lifespan: 20 to 25 years
Appearance: Natural, warm, and textured
Performance: Requires regular upkeep, can be treated for improved fire resistance

» See detailed pricing and more in our Cedar Shingle Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Beautiful, organic appearance
    • Sustainable when properly sourced
  • Cons

    • Needs regular maintenance
    • Not naturally fire-resistant

Image showing wood shakes vs wood shingles

Composite Roof Shingles

Composite shingles are made from recycled materials and engineered to mimic premium products like slate or cedar, but at a lighter weight. They’re versatile, eco-friendly, and often easier to install than natural alternatives.

Lifespan: 7 to 20 years
Appearance: Mimics slate, shake, or other traditional styles
Performance: Lightweight, lower maintenance, durability depends on the manufacturer

» Read more, including costs, in our detailed Composite Shingle Guide.

  • Pros

    • Lightweight
    • Easy to install
  • Cons

    • Not as long-lasting as slate or metal
    • Durability depends on quality

Metal Shingles

Metal roofing has grown far beyond barns and warehouses. Today’s metal shingles are sleek, stylish, and built to last. Available in steel, aluminum, copper, and more, they handle tough weather conditions better than most materials.

Lifespan: 50 to 100+ years
Appearance: Sleek, modern, or rustic, depending on the finish
Performance: Excellent durability, fire resistance, and energy efficiency

» For a full breakdown of styles, materials, and prices, see our detailed Metal Roof Cost Guide and Metal Roof Guide.

  • Pros

    • Very long-lasting
    • Energy-efficient
    • Handles extreme weather well
  • Cons

    • Higher initial cost
    • Can be noisy in heavy rain without insulation

Metal roofing shingles

Slate Shingles and Tiles

Slate is the definition of premium roofing. As a natural stone, it offers unmatched longevity and beauty, with roofs that can last over a century. Synthetic and hybrid slate options are also available for a lighter, more affordable alternative.

Lifespan: 60 to 150 years
Appearance: Classic and high-end
Performance: Extremely durable, naturally fire- and weather-resistant, but heavy

» Learn more and explore pricing ranges in our Slate Roof Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Extremely durable
    • Beautiful, natural texture
  • Cons

    • Very heavy
    • Expensive to install

Slate Roof Type - Modernize

Solar Shingles

Solar shingles are a great choice if you want a roof that works for you (literally). They generate electricity for your home while still functioning as regular roofing. They also look less industrial than solar panels, so if you’re not a fan of the look of big rectangular panels on top of a home, these provide the benefit of solar without the eyesore. You’ll pay more upfront, but they can cut down your energy costs over time.

Lifespan: 20 to 30 years
Appearance: Sleek and low profile
Performance: Produces solar energy while protecting your roof; works best in sunny climates

» See installation costs in our Solar Shingle Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Generates clean energy
    • Reduces utility bills
    • Looks less utilitarian than solar panels
  • Cons

    • High installation cost
    • Limited to sunny, south-facing areas for best performance

solar shingles

Rubber Shingles

Rubber shingles are eco-friendly and resilient, often made from recycled tires. They resemble asphalt in appearance but tend to perform better against impacts like hail.

Lifespan: 15 to 30 years
Appearance: Similar to asphalt
Performance: Strong impact resistance, energy-efficient, low maintenance

» Get a detailed cost breakdown of all rubber roof types in our Rubber Roof Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Energy efficient
    • Durable and low maintenance
    • Sustainable material
  • Cons

    • Not as widely available
    • May cost more than asphalt shingles

rubber roof shingles

Tile Roofing (Clay & Concrete)

While not technically a shingle (but what really makes a shingle a shingle?), tile roofing has been used for centuries, and for good reason. Clay tiles bring rich colors and a classic look, while concrete tiles offer a slightly more affordable but heavier alternative. Both are durable and naturally fire-resistant.

Lifespan: Up to 100 years
Appearance: Spanish or Mediterranean vibes
Performance: Long-lasting, great for hot climates, but requires a strong roof structure due to weight

» Read more and get a detailed pricing breakdown in our Tile Roofing Cost Guide.

  • Pros

    • Very durable
    • High curb appeal
    • Holds up well in hot, sunny climates
  • Cons

    • Heavy — may require additional roof support
    • Can be pricey to install

Clay tiles on a roof

What Type of Roof Shingle Is Best?

There’s no single “best” shingle type; it all comes down to what you’re hoping to accomplish. If you’re watching your budget, asphalt or composite might be the way to go. Want something that lasts for decades? Metal, clay, or slate could be a better fit. Looking to lower your energy bills? Consider rubber or solar shingles.

Think about what matters most to you — cost, appearance, sustainability, or durability — and let that guide your decision.

Ready to start
your project?

FAQ: Roof Shingles

What type of roof shingles last the longest?

Slate and metal shingles typically offer the longest lifespans. Slate can last 60 to 150 years, while metal shingles often last 50 years or more with proper maintenance.

Which shingles are best for hot or sunny climates?

Tile, slate, and metal shingles handle heat and direct sun especially well. They reflect or withstand heat without deteriorating quickly, making them popular choices in warm-weather regions.

What type of shingles are best for energy efficiency?

Metal, rubber, and solar shingles are considered the most energy-efficient roof materials. Metal reflects sunlight, rubber insulates well, and solar shingles generate renewable electricity directly from your roof.

What are the most environmentally friendly roofing shingles?

Composite, rubber, and solar shingles often use recycled or sustainable materials and can reduce your carbon footprint compared to traditional asphalt. Cedar is also eco-friendly when sourced responsibly.

How do I choose the right type of shingle for my home?

Think about your priorities — whether that’s budget, appearance, durability, or sustainability. Asphalt shingles are affordable and versatile, cedar provides natural charm, slate and tile offer luxury and longevity, and solar shingles add renewable energy benefits.

Share this article